I recently received a check for $10.59 as my total payment in a class action suit. I was one of more than 600,000 participants. The gross settlement was well over $100,000,000, and the class action attorneys’ fees exceeded $20,000,000.
Over the years, I’ve accumulated a folder with similar trivial distributions from class action suits. The defendants in these cases—the companies we do business with—pass the costs of the penalties on to us, along with the associated legal, administrative, and insurance expenses. We also invest in these companies, indirectly though banks, mutual funds, and retirement plans, or through direct investment. The costs of those lawsuits reduce our return on investment. And we pay for the associated costs of the court system, through taxes and fees—more money out of our pockets.
Just as with companies and organizations, the long-term success of our society is affected by the overall consequences of our methods for solving problems. Are we serving the greater need, or are we screwing things up with too much emphasis on just one piece of the puzzle?
Some class action suits are beneficial. But some of these lawsuits do nothing more than transfer a great deal of money from the public to a few private pockets. Society pays for this. I pay for this. And you pay for this. So thank you for your $10.59.
George M. Pomonik
Pomonik Consulting, Inc.
“Chaos Removal Services”SM
www.pomonik.com
Copyright © George M. Pomonik, 2012. All rights reserved.
I think that cooperative prevention works better than an adversarial “hit to the wallet”. Would you rather prevent a tragedy, or sue somebody after it happens? I am impressed by Dr. Gawande’s book on “The Checklist Manifesto: How to Get Things Right”. It provides strong evidence that well-designed checklists and effective communications can prevent serious problems in surgery, aviation, investment, and construction. It also makes the case that similar methods can be highly beneficial in many other key areas.
“Thank you for your $10.59” isn’t intended to bash lawyers. The law and its experts are essential parts of our civilization. As with most complex issues, frivolous lawsuits are symptoms of problems in our overall system, and we all own responsibility. Remedies include greater prevention of problems by the organizations providing products and services, citizens taking responsibility for their own safety, well-balanced laws and enforcement, and the leadership to tie it all together.
I agree with many points you made. But I am still of the belief in some areas that the only way they listen is to lose money. Sometimes a hit to the wallet allows the pain to occur. What other ideas can we come up with to make our voices heard?
Do you know how cold it is in New York? The lawyers are walking around with their hands in their own pockets.